Specialized Physical Therapy for Men, Women & Children | Licensed in South Carolina
A shoulder that slips during a reach, feels close to coming out when the arm is rotated backward, or becomes difficult to control during throwing can have different underlying problems. Stability depends on the shape of the joint, the integrity of its surrounding tissues, and the muscular forces controlling movement. A labral tear describes a structural finding, while instability describes symptomatic loss of joint control. Either can occur without the other, and pain during overhead activity does not establish that the shoulder is slipping. [1,2]
The rounded head of the humerus, the upper arm bone, rests against a shallow socket called the glenoid. The labrum forms a rim around that socket, increasing its depth and providing attachment for parts of the capsule and ligaments. These tissues provide restraint beyond what the shallow bony socket supplies alone. [3]
The capsule is a connective tissue envelope surrounding the joint. Its ligamentous reinforcements become tensioned differently as the arm changes position. Near the limits of movement, particular regions resist further displacement. Damage to a capsular attachment can therefore leave the shoulder vulnerable in one position while other movements remain comfortable and dependable. [3]
The rotator cuff compresses the humeral head against the socket while helping balance the forces produced by larger muscles moving the arm. Compression against a concave surface resists sideways displacement, provided the socket and its rim offer adequate support. Muscles moving the shoulder blade also change the socket’s orientation beneath the arm. Stability depends on how these forces work together, not simply the strength of one muscle. [3,4]
Some translation, or movement of the humeral head relative to the socket, is normal. Laxity describes how much movement is available, whereas instability describes movement that produces symptoms or loss of function. A naturally flexible shoulder can remain comfortable and stable, while a shoulder with less overall flexibility can become unstable in a particular direction. Greater movement does not automatically require treatment. [2]
A dislocation occurs when the humeral head completely loses its normal relationship with the socket. A subluxation is a partial displacement that can resolve without the shoulder remaining visibly out of position. Apprehension is the sensation that the shoulder is about to slip, often when approaching a previously vulnerable position. Pain can accompany these experiences, but pain alone does not establish displacement. [1,5]
Anterior instability involves movement toward the front of the socket, often with the arm raised and rotated backward. Posterior instability involves movement toward the back and can become symptomatic during loading with the arm in front of the body. Multidirectional instability produces symptoms in more than one direction. The direction influences which positions initially need protection and which demands rehabilitation must eventually restore. [1,5]
A suspected current dislocation requires emergency medical assessment. If an injury leaves the shoulder visibly changed in shape, severely painful, or unable to move normally, support the arm in its most comfortable position and do not try to pull it back into place. Numbness, marked weakness, or a cold or pale hand raises concern about nerve or circulation injury. Assessment is still necessary if the shoulder appears to relocate on its own because associated injuries can remain. [6]
Persistent inability to lift the arm after a treated dislocation warrants prompt reassessment. Rotator cuff tears and nerve injuries can accompany the event, particularly in older adults. New weakness should not automatically be attributed to soreness or managed by repeatedly attempting heavier exercise. [1]
A traumatic dislocation can detach the labrum, damage the capsule, or injure bone. Relocating the shoulder restores the position of the joint surfaces without immediately restoring the injured restraints. Subsequent symptoms depend on the tissues damaged, recovery, activity demands, and the muscular support available. [1,3]
Instability can also develop without a major injury. Some people have greater underlying laxity combined with difficulty coordinating the muscles controlling the joint. Repeated loading near the limits of movement can contribute to symptoms and, in some cases, structural changes. Atraumatic instability can occur with structurally intact passive restraints, so a scan without a major tear does not invalidate recurrent slipping or loss of control. [2]
Treatment needs to address the source of the instability. Tightening tissue does not necessarily correct a predominantly muscular control problem, and exercise cannot replace a missing piece of socket bone. Rehabilitation is generally the initial treatment for atraumatic instability. Surgery requires an identifiable structural target and particular caution when altered muscle recruitment is the dominant problem. [2]
A Bankart injury affects the labrum and associated capsular attachment at the front and lower portion of the socket, commonly after an anterior dislocation. Detachment compromises part of the socket rim and an attachment of the tissues resisting forward displacement. A SLAP injury affects the upper labrum near the attachment of the long head of the biceps tendon. The abbreviation means superior labrum anterior to posterior and identifies a different anatomical region. [3,7]
SLAP findings vary in substance. Surface fraying with the attachment still intact differs from detachment of the upper labrum and biceps anchor. Pull through the biceps attachment and torsion during overhead movement have been proposed as injury mechanisms, but the cause cannot be reconstructed from an MRI alone. [7]
Imaging findings need to be interpreted alongside symptoms. In a study of adults aged 45 to 60 with no shoulder symptoms, radiologists frequently interpreted MRI appearances as superior labral tears. Such findings require caution in that age group; they should not be treated as equivalent to a newly traumatic detachment in a younger person. [8]
Clicking or catching alone does not diagnose a SLAP injury, and a painful shoulder can have more than one abnormal finding. Treatment should address the explanation that best fits the injury and functional problem rather than assuming that the most striking phrase in an imaging report identifies the source of pain. [7]
Throwing combines a large range of rotation with rapid force production and braking. The arm rotates backward during preparation, accelerates toward release, and then must be slowed. During deceleration, muscles resist the continuing movement of the arm while lengthening under load, a form of contraction called eccentric muscle action. The ability to produce a powerful throw does not automatically provide the ability to repeatedly absorb its remaining energy. [9]
The legs and trunk contribute energy before it reaches the arm, while the shoulder blade moves to orient the socket as the arm changes position. Reduced contribution or altered timing elsewhere can change shoulder demands. Observing a movement difference does not, however, prove that it caused an injury. Much of this detailed research comes from baseball pitching and cannot be applied unchanged to every overhead activity. [9]
Overhead work creates different demands from throwing. Holding a tool above shoulder height requires sustained effort, while throwing requires rapid force production, braking, and recovery between repetitions. A shoulder can manage dressing and occasional reaching but become painful or less controlled during a work shift or practice. A brief strength test does not reproduce those repeated or prolonged demands. [4,5]
Throwing also requires enough rotation for performance without losing control of that range. Some movement differences develop as adaptations to the sport rather than disease. More flexibility is not automatically better, and making both shoulders identical is not always an appropriate goal. Overhead pain can arise from cuff, labral, mobility, or other problems without symptomatic instability. [7,10]
Rehabilitation improves the muscular support and movement abilities available around the joint. Better function after exercise does not prove that a detached labrum has reattached or that every structural abnormality has healed. It demonstrates that the shoulder is managing the practiced and tested demands more successfully. [4,5]
Early practice can reduce the demand enough to allow controlled movement. Supporting the forearm on a table, for example, reduces the effort required to hold up the arm while rotation is practiced. Removing support, raising the arm, or adding resistance then increases different aspects of the task. The starting position and progression depend on the direction of instability and any healing restrictions rather than a universal exercise sequence. [4]
Strength provides the force required for a task, while endurance allows that force to be sustained or repeated. Movement control coordinates the direction and timing of muscular action as the arm moves or encounters an unexpected load. Rehabilitation can therefore progress from controlled resistance to repeated movement and eventually catching, braking, or responding to changing forces when those demands are relevant. A person can have adequate strength for a single effort yet struggle as repetitions accumulate. [5]
Confidence develops through successful practice as the demands increase. Repeatedly provoking a slip is not a useful test of progress. If an exercise produces displacement, increasing apprehension, or declining control, stop that version and have the position or demand reviewed. [4,5]
Activity changes should reduce the demand causing difficulty without unnecessarily abandoning all arm use. If sustained overhead work provokes symptoms, shorter work periods or safely repositioning the task can reduce time spent with the arm elevated. Progression then needs to restore the duration and working position actually required, not merely the ability to perform a few light repetitions. [4,5]
For throwing, volume, distance, and effort represent different demands. An individualized return program can adjust them separately rather than resuming full practice at once. Recurrent slipping or a progressive loss of control requires reassessment, even if pain settles quickly afterward. Returning sooner with nonsurgical care can carry a substantial recurrence risk in high demand athletes and should not be treated as evidence that the injured restraints have healed. [11]
Research supports rehabilitation as initial care for atraumatic instability without establishing one optimal exercise program. If symptoms persist, review the diagnosis, exercise selection, progression, and structural considerations rather than indefinitely repeating an unchanged strengthening routine. A program that is appropriate for one direction or mechanism of instability may not address another. [2,12]
Recurrent dislocations or subluxations, persistent functional instability, or inability to progress despite appropriate rehabilitation warrant specialist review. Younger people returning to collision sport or other high risk activity may also need an early discussion after a first traumatic dislocation. Treatment choices depend on recurrence risk, associated injuries, and the consequences of another event, not age alone. [1,11]
Bone injury changes the available support. Loss of the socket rim reduces the surface containing the humeral head. A Hill Sachs lesion is a compression defect in the humeral head created when it strikes the socket edge during an anterior dislocation. Some defects can catch against the rim in vulnerable positions, especially when socket bone is also missing. Their combined geometry can make a soft tissue repair insufficient. [3]
Recurrent episodes can be associated with additional bone loss, although progressive damage is not inevitable after every slip. Imaging is used when necessary to define the defects and plan treatment. Persistent instability can justify specialist discussion before repeated complete dislocations occur. [3,11]
A Bankart repair uses sutures and anchors to reattach injured labral and capsular tissue to the socket. Capsular tightening reduces excessive capsular volume, while bone augmentation restores support when socket bone loss makes a soft tissue repair inadequate. The operation should address the particular deficiency rather than treating all instability as a labral tear requiring the same repair. [3,10]
Surgery has tradeoffs. Excessive tightening can limit rotation needed for throwing, while insufficient restraint can leave recurrent instability. When disturbed muscle recruitment is the principal problem without a suitable structural target, surgery may not correct the cause of disability. A painful SLAP finding also requires its own decision, usually after nonsurgical treatment, rather than automatic stabilization or repair. [2,7,10]
Sutures hold repaired tissue in position while biological attachment develops. They do not immediately create a mature attachment capable of tolerating unrestricted force. Rehabilitation must balance protection with recovery of movement, following restrictions specific to the repair rather than using pain alone to decide what is safe. [13]
Later return decisions must examine the demands that remain. Motion and strength testing contribute information, but repeated overhead work, throwing, and contact require task specific preparation. Time remains relevant to healing without being a complete measure of readiness. No single performance test guarantees that instability will not recur, and comfortable daily function does not guarantee return to previous overhead performance. [13,14]
Brownson P, Donaldson O, Fox M, et al. BESS/BOA Patient Care Pathways: Traumatic anterior shoulder instability. Shoulder & Elbow. 2015;7(3):214–226. doi:10.1177/1758573215585656.
Noorani A, Goldring M, Jaggi A, Gibson J, Rees J, Bateman M, Falworth M, Brownson P. BESS/BOA patient care pathways: Atraumatic shoulder instability. Shoulder & Elbow. 2019;11(1):60–70. doi:10.1177/1758573218815002.
Keeling LE, Wagala N, Ryan PM, Gilbert R, Hughes JD. Bone loss in shoulder instability: putting it all together. Annals of Joint. 2023;8:27. doi:10.21037/aoj-23-6.
Jaggi A, Alexander S. Rehabilitation for Shoulder Instability: Current Approaches. The Open Orthopaedics Journal. 2017;11:957–971. doi:10.2174/1874325001711010957.
Olds M, Uhl TL. Current Clinical Concepts: Nonoperative Management of Shoulder Instability. Journal of Athletic Training. 2024;59(3):243–254. doi:10.4085/1062-6050-0468.22.
Rozzi SL, Anderson JM, Doberstein ST, Godek JJ, Hartsock LA, McFarland EG. National Athletic Trainers’ Association Position Statement: Immediate Management of Appendicular Joint Dislocations. Journal of Athletic Training. 2018;53(12):1117–1128. doi:10.4085/1062-6050-97-12.
Michener LA, Abrams JS, Huxel Bliven KC, Falsone S, Laudner KG, McFarland EG, Tibone JE, Thigpen CA, Uhl TL. National Athletic Trainers’ Association Position Statement: Evaluation, Management, and Outcomes of and Return-to-Play Criteria for Overhead Athletes With Superior Labral Anterior-Posterior Injuries. Journal of Athletic Training. 2018;53(3):209–229. doi:10.4085/1062-6050-59-16.
Schwartzberg R, Reuss BL, Burkhart BG, Butterfield M, Wu JY, McLean KW. High Prevalence of Superior Labral Tears Diagnosed by MRI in Middle-Aged Patients With Asymptomatic Shoulders. Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine. 2016;4(1):2325967115623212. doi:10.1177/2325967115623212.
Mayes M, Salesky M, Lansdown DA. Throwing Injury Prevention Strategies with a Whole Kinetic Chain-Focused Approach. Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine. 2022;15(2):53–64. doi:10.1007/s12178-022-09744-9.
Arguello AM, Till SE, Reinholz AK, Okoroha KR, Barlow JD, Camp CL. Managing Shoulder Instability in the Overhead Athlete. Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine. 2022;15(6):552–560. doi:10.1007/s12178-022-09796-x.
Albertson BS, Trasolini NA, Rue JPH, Waterman BR. In-Season Management of Shoulder Instability: How to Evaluate, Treat, and Safely Return to Sport. Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine. 2023;16(7):295–305. doi:10.1007/s12178-023-09838-y.
Griffin J, Jaggi A, Daniell H, Chester R. A systematic review to compare physiotherapy treatment programmes for atraumatic shoulder instability. Shoulder & Elbow. 2023;15(4):448–460. doi:10.1177/17585732221080730.
Ma R, Brimmo OA, Li X, Colbert L. Current Concepts in Rehabilitation for Traumatic Anterior Shoulder Instability. Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine. 2017;10(4):499–506. doi:10.1007/s12178-017-9449-9.
Schwank A, Blazey P, Asker M, Møller M, Hägglund M, Gard S, Skazalski C, Andersson SH, Horsley I, Whiteley R, Cools AM, Bizzini M, Ardern CL. 2022 Bern Consensus Statement on Shoulder Injury Prevention, Rehabilitation, and Return to Sport for Athletes at All Participation Levels. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy. 2022;52(1):11–28. doi:10.2519/jospt.2022.10952.