Specialized Physical Therapy for Men, Women & Children | Licensed in South Carolina
Thumb base arthritis often becomes noticeable during tasks that require surprisingly little movement. Turning a key, fastening a clasp, opening a food packet, or lifting a mug can produce pain where the thumb meets the wrist. The difficulty is not necessarily the weight of the object. A small object held between the thumb and a finger can require substantial force inside the thumb’s base joint, particularly when the grip must also resist twisting or slipping. Arthritis changes the surfaces and support of that joint, making these ordinary demands harder to tolerate.[1,2]
The affected joint is usually the first carpometacarpal joint, commonly called the thumb CMC joint or basal joint. Treatment can reduce symptoms and make hand use easier without restoring the original cartilage. Decisions about braces, rehabilitation, injections, and surgery depend on which activities are limited, how the thumb behaves under load, and whether the expected benefit justifies the treatment’s demands and risks.[2,3]
The thumb CMC joint connects the first metacarpal, the long bone within the thumb side of the palm, to the trapezium, a small wrist bone. Its opposing surfaces have a saddle shape, curving in different directions rather than forming a simple hinge. This arrangement allows the thumb to move away from the palm, travel across it, and rotate so that its pad faces the fingers. That combined movement, called opposition, places the thumb around a cup, against a pen, or opposite the fingertips during a precise pinch.[1,4]
Once positioned, the thumb must remain sufficiently stable while the fingers push against it. Ligaments connect the bones and restrain excessive movement, while muscles position the metacarpal and generate the forces needed to hold an object. These muscle forces also compress the joint. Because muscles act through short lever arms close to the joint, producing force at the thumb tip requires considerably greater force within the CMC joint. The internal demand can therefore be substantial even when the object itself is light.[1,4]
Different grips place different demands on this system. Holding a key against the side of the index finger requires lateral pinch. Holding a needle requires precise fingertip contact. Gripping a saucepan handle requires the thumb to oppose the fingers while the hand resists the weight and rotation of the pan. Difficulty with one task does not establish that every form of hand use is equally limited, and a treatment that makes writing comfortable may still leave heavy gripping difficult.[1,4]
Articular cartilage covers the contacting bone surfaces and provides a smooth surface for movement and load transmission. In osteoarthritis, this cartilage deteriorates, while the bone beneath it and the surrounding joint tissues also change. The bone can become denser beneath the joint surface and develop projections called osteophytes. The joint lining, or synovium, can become inflamed. These changes affect how the joint moves, transmits force, and responds to loading.[2,4,5]
The joint’s support and alignment can change as well. The metacarpal can become partly displaced relative to the trapezium, a finding called subluxation. Altered contact between the surfaces changes where force is transmitted. In some thumbs, the metacarpal also moves toward the palm, reducing the space between the thumb and index finger. These changes can make it harder to open the hand around a broad object or position the thumb effectively for pinch.[1,4]
Joint shape, ligament characteristics, age, inherited susceptibility, prior injury, and loading history contribute to the condition. Repetitive or forceful use can aggravate symptoms, but identifying a painful activity does not establish that the activity caused the arthritis. Anatomical and biomechanical research has identified several plausible contributors without establishing one sequence that explains every affected thumb.[4]
Established cartilage loss is not reliably reversed by exercises, medication, or an injection. These treatments instead change symptoms, external support, movement demands, or the performance of the surrounding muscles. A person can become more comfortable and capable while the joint still looks arthritic on an X ray, so treatment benefit should be judged by symptoms and useful hand activity rather than an expectation that the image will return to normal.[3,6]
Cartilage itself does not contain the nerves that generate pain. Other joint tissues, including the synovium and bone beneath the cartilage, are innervated. Inflammation and changes in these tissues can contribute to tenderness and pain during loading. The phrase “bone on bone” describes advanced loss of joint space, but it does not identify every contributor to pain or explain why symptoms vary from one day to another.[5]
In a study following people with hand osteoarthritis, changes in thumb base tenderness were associated with changes in joint lining inflammation and bone marrow abnormalities on MRI, even after accounting for radiographic damage. The study did not prove that one finding caused an individual’s symptoms. Its findings support a relationship between pain and changes in tissues other than cartilage, allowing symptoms to fluctuate without a comparable change in the joint space seen on an X ray.[5]
A painful thumb can feel weak because producing force hurts or because the joint no longer provides an effective mechanical base. That differs from muscle atrophy, which means a reduction in muscle size. Difficulty opening a jar does not by itself establish that the thumb muscles have wasted away. Strength, the ability to generate force, also differs from endurance, the ability to sustain or repeat effort. Someone may manage one firm pinch but struggle with several minutes of fastening buttons or preparing food.[1,6]
As the base becomes less mobile or changes position, the next joint toward the thumb tip can compensate. This is the metacarpophalangeal joint, or MCP joint, at the thumb’s main knuckle. It can bend backward excessively during pinch, producing hyperextension. The thumb may still reach the object, but the knuckle’s backward movement can make it a less effective support for forceful pinch. A flexible compensation that can be controlled during light use differs from a fixed deformity that cannot be corrected actively. That difference can influence brace design, rehabilitation goals, and surgical planning.[7]
An X ray can show narrowing of the space between the bones, osteophytes, altered alignment, and arthritis in neighboring joints. The apparent joint space represents cartilage indirectly because cartilage is not visible on a standard X ray. These findings help establish the structural pattern and become particularly useful when planning an operation.[2,8]
Structural severity does not provide a complete measurement of disability. Imaging findings have associations with pain, but their relationships with hand function and future progression are less consistent. An X ray cannot show how long someone can hold a tool, whether a particular brace permits comfortable work, or how much a painful thumb limits caregiving. Those experiences remain part of the treatment decision rather than being replaced by a radiographic stage.[8]
Pain near the thumb base can also come from another structure. Tendon disorders, injury, nerve compression, and arthritis in adjacent wrist joints can coexist with CMC arthritis. Persistent numbness, a new injury, or symptoms that do not fit the expected pattern deserve reassessment rather than being attributed automatically to an arthritic X ray.[2,9]
Activity adaptation changes how much force the thumb must produce, how long it must sustain that force, or how the force reaches the joint. For someone whose symptoms are provoked by forceful pinch, replacing repeated pinching with a broader grip or mechanical aid can preserve the activity while making it more manageable.[3,9]
A jar opener can supply leverage that would otherwise come from a strong thumb and finger grip. A key turner enlarges the surface held by the hand, reducing reliance on a narrow lateral pinch. A thicker pen barrel changes how tightly the thumb must press against the fingers. Supporting a heavy dish underneath with both hands changes the task from holding its rim in a sustained pinch to carrying its weight across larger contact areas. These are applications of ergonomic principles, not evidence that one handle size or grip is best for every arthritic thumb.[1,9]
Duration and repetition can be changed separately from force. Someone who tolerates a short period of pruning but develops prolonged aching after an uninterrupted session could divide the work into shorter periods or alternate it with tasks requiring less gripping. When reintroducing a demanding activity, the initial trial can involve a lighter object, less resistance, or a shorter period of use. The response includes whether later swelling, aching, or loss of hand use increases, not just whether the task was possible at the time.[9]
Adaptations should be judged against the activity they are intended to improve. An aid that requires an awkward grip, transfers the problem to the wrist, or leaves the limiting symptoms unchanged needs adjustment or replacement. Research supports assistive devices for improving function in hand osteoarthritis, but the evidence does not identify one device that suits every person or task.[6]
An orthosis is a brace designed to support or restrict selected joints. For thumb base arthritis, it provides external support around the CMC region to reduce painful movement or loading. Some designs leave the wrist and thumb knuckle free; others include one or both when additional support is needed. A softer brace may be easier to use during some activities, while a more rigid design provides greater restriction.[3,10]
The brace should be selected around the thumb’s behavior and the task. If the MCP joint bends backward during pinch, a short brace supporting only the base may leave that compensation unchanged. Conversely, restricting the wrist unnecessarily can interfere with otherwise comfortable activities. Pressure over a bony prominence, new numbness, skin injury, or increased pain requires adjustment rather than tighter straps.[7,9]
Thumb CMC orthoses are strongly recommended in the American College of Rheumatology and Arthritis Foundation guideline. Trials support symptom relief, but they do not establish one universally superior material, design, or wearing schedule. An orthosis does not rebuild cartilage or reliably reverse an established deformity. Feeling stronger while wearing one can reflect improved external support and less pain rather than increased muscle strength.[9,10]
Rehabilitation addresses the abilities needed for the activities that remain difficult. Mobility work concerns the available movement needed to place the thumb around an object or bring its pad toward the fingers. Coordination work concerns how the joints and muscles cooperate during that movement. Strength work concerns force production, while endurance work concerns maintaining or repeating effort. Increasing resistance does not address every limitation, particularly when the movement remains poorly controlled or the required position is unavailable.[1,9]
For a thumb that collapses at the knuckle during light pinch, practice might begin with maintaining a manageable thumb position against low resistance. Increasing resistance before that position can be controlled can turn the exercise into repeated practice of the same collapse. For someone who produces force comfortably but tires during sewing, the relevant progression may concern repeated precision work rather than stronger squeezing. These are examples of applying rehabilitation principles, not a prescription for one thumb posture or exercise in every case.[1]
The muscles around the thumb and the first dorsal interosseous muscle, located between the thumb and index metacarpals, contribute to the mechanics of pinch. Their training is intended to improve active performance around the joint. It cannot recreate the original cartilage surface, eliminate every degree of subluxation, or guarantee that a particular muscle has corrected the arthritis. Much of the rationale for specific stabilizing exercises comes from anatomical and biomechanical work rather than trials demonstrating prevention of structural progression.[1,4]
Exercise studies have tested different combinations of movement, resistance, coordination, and functional practice. Average benefits are generally modest, and the evidence does not establish one optimal schedule. In the COMBO trial, adding a brace, exercises, and topical diclofenac to education produced a small additional improvement in hand function at six weeks, without a significant additional pain benefit at that primary time point. Because treatments were combined, the trial cannot establish which component produced the improvement.[6,11]
An exercise that repeatedly produces a substantial flare should be reviewed for resistance, movement range, technique, and relevance to the person’s goal. Less pain immediately after a session does not prove that cartilage has healed, and a stronger pinch test does not establish readiness for prolonged tool use. Progress should include the ability to perform the intended activity with sufficient movement control, force, and endurance, alongside an acceptable symptom response.[6,11]
Topical nonsteroidal anti inflammatory medication, such as diclofenac gel, is an option for local symptom relief. It reduces production of chemicals involved in pain and inflammation rather than restoring the joint surface. Hand osteoarthritis guidelines generally favor considering topical medication before systemic treatment because less medication reaches the rest of the body.[9,10,12]
Topical treatment still has precautions. Diclofenac can cause skin reactions and carries warnings concerning bleeding, cardiovascular disease, kidney problems, and allergy to aspirin or other NSAIDs. Ask a clinician or pharmacist before combining it with ibuprofen, naproxen, another NSAID, or a blood thinner. Follow the specific product’s directions, including its duration limit, and do not apply external heat or a bandage over the treated area. Pregnancy requires specific advice, particularly from 20 weeks onward because NSAIDs can harm fetal kidney function and reduce amniotic fluid.[12]
Oral NSAIDs can reduce symptoms but require consideration of gastrointestinal bleeding, kidney disease, cardiovascular risk, and medication interactions. When appropriate, they are used at the lowest effective dose for the shortest necessary period. Acetaminophen is another option for selected patients, although its average benefit for osteoarthritis is limited. Liver disease, alcohol intake, and duplicate ingredients in other products affect its safety.[9,10]
A corticosteroid injection places an anti inflammatory medicine inside the joint to reduce symptoms. It does not rebuild cartilage or mechanically stabilize the thumb. Evidence for thumb base injections is inconsistent: the British hand surgery guideline recommends considering an injection when noninvasive treatment has not provided sufficient relief, whereas EULAR advises against routine use for hand osteoarthritis because thumb base trials have not established reliable benefit. An injection is a selective option rather than a predictable next step.[3,9]
Potential adverse effects include a temporary pain flare, skin thinning or color change, infection, and a temporary rise in blood glucose. Diabetes, anticoagulant use, possible infection, and previous injections should be reviewed beforehand. Relief does not prove that inflammation was the only source of pain, and the amount or duration of benefit does not establish structural healing. A poorly effective injection should prompt reconsideration rather than automatic repetition.[13]
Surgical Changes to the Joint
Surgery is considered when pain and loss of useful hand function remain unacceptable despite an appropriate nonsurgical approach. The decision is not based on the X ray alone. Work demands, the condition of adjacent joints, thumb knuckle deformity, recovery requirements, and the person’s priorities influence which operation is reasonable.[3,7,8]
A common operation is trapeziectomy, removal of the trapezium. This eliminates the arthritic contact between the trapezium and thumb metacarpal rather than recreating the original saddle joint. The thumb subsequently functions through a different arrangement of bone and surrounding soft tissues.[14]
Some procedures add ligament reconstruction, tendon interposition, or a suspension technique intended to support the metacarpal after trapezium removal. Tendon interposition places tissue in the space, while suspension procedures support the metacarpal using tendon or other material. The mechanical rationale for these additions has not translated into a consistent clinical advantage. The 2026 Cochrane review found low certainty evidence that adding ligament reconstruction and tendon interposition provides little or no additional benefit over trapeziectomy alone for several important outcomes.[3,14,15]
Fusion joins the bones so that the arthritic surfaces no longer move against each other, trading movement at that joint for stability and requiring the bones to unite. Implant replacement attempts to preserve an articulation but introduces risks such as loosening or dislocation. Comparative evidence does not identify one operation as best for every patient. Suitability depends on anatomy, demands, the evidence for the procedure, and the consequences of a potential failure.[14,15]
The incision and deeper tissues need to heal before the thumb returns to unrestricted gripping. Tendon or ligament procedures require healing around the reconstruction, a fusion requires bone union, and implant procedures have their own protection requirements. Early protection and later rehabilitation therefore depend on the operation performed rather than pain alone.[14,15]
Postoperative rehabilitation initially balances protection with recovery of appropriate movement. Later work develops controlled pinch, grip, and endurance as healing permits. A closed incision or comfortable light task does not establish readiness for sustained twisting, heavy lifting, or forceful tool use. Return decisions should account for both the surgical tissues and the demands of the intended activity.[14]
Improvement develops over months. The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons notes that final results after CMC arthroplasty can take nine to twelve months, although individual recovery varies. Pain relief and improved everyday use do not guarantee normal pinch strength or unrestricted heavy work. Persistent pain, sensory nerve symptoms, wound problems, tendon injury, or failure requiring further surgery remain possible.[14]
A suddenly hot, red, markedly swollen, or severely painful thumb requires urgent assessment rather than treatment as an ordinary arthritis flare, particularly with fever or feeling unwell. After an injury, a change in shape, inability to move the thumb or hold objects, or loss of sensation also warrants urgent evaluation. These symptoms require assessment for an acute problem rather than adjustment of an arthritis exercise program.[16]
Persistent numbness, progressive weakness, increasing deformity, or declining hand use despite treatment warrants reassessment. The next decision could concern a different brace, a revised rehabilitation demand, evaluation of an adjacent structure, or consultation with a hand specialist. Brief pain relief is not sufficient evidence of successful management when the ability to perform necessary activities continues to deteriorate.[3,7,9]
Neumann DA, Bielefeld T. The carpometacarpal joint of the thumb: stability, deformity, and therapeutic intervention. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy. 2003;33(7):386–399. doi:10.2519/jospt.2003.33.7.386.
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Arthritis of the thumb. OrthoInfo. Accessed November 22, 2026.
Gangopadhyay S, Jansen V, Khor WS, Gardiner MD, Burchette D, McKenna H. Guideline on managing thumb base osteoarthritis: The British Society for Surgery of the Hand Evidence for Surgical Treatment (BEST) findings and recommendations. Journal of Hand Surgery (European Volume). 2025;50(5):576–586. doi:10.1177/17531934241313206.
Ladd AL, Crisco JJ, Hagert E, Rose J, Weiss APC. The 2014 ABJS Nicolas Andry Award: the puzzle of the thumb: mobility, stability, and demands in opposition. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. 2014;472(12):3605–3622. doi:10.1007/s11999-014-3901-6.
van Beest S, Kroon HM, Reijnierse M, Rosendaal FR, Kloppenburg M, Kroon FPB. Two-year changes in magnetic resonance imaging features and pain in thumb base osteoarthritis. Arthritis Care & Research. 2021;73(11):1628–1637. doi:10.1002/acr.24355.
Kjeken I, Bordvik DH, Østerås N, et al. Efficacy and safety of non-pharmacological, pharmacological and surgical treatments for hand osteoarthritis in 2024: a systematic review. RMD Open. 2025;11(1):e004963. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2024-004963.
Morrell NT, Menon N, Nolan JE. Management of thumb metacarpophalangeal hyperextension in the setting of thumb basal joint arthritis. Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. 2022;30(15):703–710. doi:10.5435/JAAOS-D-21-00981.
Mazza DF, Boonsri PS, Arora A, Bayne CO, Szabo RM, Chaudhari AJ, Boutin RD. Relationships between diagnostic imaging of first carpometacarpal osteoarthritis and pain, functional status, and disease progression: a systematic review. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage. 2024;32(5):476–492. doi:10.1016/j.joca.2023.11.023.
Kloppenburg M, Kroon FPB, Blanco FJ, et al. 2018 update of the EULAR recommendations for the management of hand osteoarthritis. Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases. 2019;78(1):16–24. doi:10.1136/annrheumdis-2018-213826.
Kolasinski SL, Neogi T, Hochberg MC, et al. 2019 American College of Rheumatology/Arthritis Foundation Guideline for the Management of Osteoarthritis of the Hand, Hip, and Knee. Arthritis Care & Research. 2020;72(2):149–162. doi:10.1002/acr.24131.
Deveza LA, Robbins SR, Duong V, et al. Efficacy of a combination of conservative therapies vs an education comparator on clinical outcomes in thumb base osteoarthritis: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Internal Medicine. 2021;181(4):429–438. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2020.7101.
National Library of Medicine. Diclofenac sodium topical gel, 1%: Drug Facts and consumer information. DailyMed. Accessed November 22, 2026.
American College of Rheumatology. Joint injections (joint aspirations). Patient education. Accessed November 22, 2026.
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Thumb carpometacarpal (CMC) arthroplasty. OrthoInfo. Accessed November 22, 2026.
Baljer B, Vinycomb T, Low N. Surgery for thumb (trapeziometacarpal joint) osteoarthritis. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2026;5:CD004631. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD004631.pub6.
National Health Service. Thumb pain. Accessed November 22, 2026.